Friday, November 22, 2024

Anxiety & Appreciation: My annual tree trimming exercise

I expanded my annual "tree trimming" exercise this year to include several shrubs that have gotten too large and unwieldy for me to handle on my own.  Although I have great trust in the company I've used since February 2013, there's always some collateral damage associated with the process.  Last year several large Agave attenuata rosettes and one Agave colorata suffered severe cases of what's often called "agave edema."  They were so damaged that I removed them.  I made a point of showing the arborist photos of the damage when we discussed this year's plans and he took precautions to prevent a repeat of that problem.  But the sheer volume of the debris created during the pruning process and the height from which many large branches fall, as well as the cleanup required at ground level, means that some plants on the ground will inadvertently be broken, stomped on, or dislodged.  This year wasn't as bad but then maybe I'm finally getting more accepting of the balance of the good and the bad associated with the process.

Here are the before and after shots, starting with the three shrubs I included in the trimming process this year:

My husband was disappointed that the height of the Callistemon 'Cane's Hybrid' in the back garden wasn't reduced but my objective was only to thin it down to reduce the heaviness of the branches

The same was true in the case of the 2 tree-sized 'Copper Glow' Leptospermums in the front garden


Ten trees were pruned:

This view shows the smaller of the 2 Arbutus 'Marina' in the back garden.  I delayed pruning this year principally because these trees were laden with flowers in September and I didn't want to disappoint the hummingbirds that flocked to them well into October.

This is the larger of the 2 Arbutus in the back garden

This is a shot of the interior of that tree's canopy.  I have all 4 of our Arbutus pruned each year to improve air flow and prevent the black soot that otherwise develops on the leaves.

This is a before and after comparison of the Arbutus on the north end of the front garden.  The succulents below the tree were those so severely impacted last year.  There were no problems of that nature this year.

The "before" photo of the Arbutus (left) on the south end of the front garden was marred by sun spots but it otherwise clearly shows the tree's appearance prior to pruning.  It sits atop a moderate slope so pruning it without causing damage to the area below it is particularly difficult.

The Hong Kong orchid tree (Bauhinia x blakeana) doesn't look much different does it?  All I had done there was to have a few dead branch tips removed.

These before and after shots of the 3 citrus trees bordering the cutting garden (a Mandarin orange, a navel orange, and a lime) also don't look much different.  However, all the dead branches were removed, which I could see when I viewed them close up, even if the change isn't reflected in these wide shots.  The trees are also in need to feeding, which I'll do in early spring.

These are photos of the Magnolia grandiflora in the front garden

This photo taken from the path leading to the front door shows how open the area below the Magnolia's canopy is now.  The light level is much better for all the plants below the tree.

The canopy of the ornamental pear tree (Pyrus calleryana) was thinned and some of the lower branches were cut off or shortened.  Before the pruning, I couldn't walk below some of them without ducking in places.


The crew also cleaned up the cherry laurel hedge that runs along one section of the property line in the front garden:

The 5 Prunus caroliniana shrubs that make up the hedge just get sheared to neaten them up but the crew has to be careful of the lath house, which they were.  My husband recently made repairs to the roof, which was damaged by last year's heavy rainfall.


There were also three removals on the agenda:

This peach tree came with the garden, although we didn't discover it until the massive Yucca was removed along the property line at the bottom of the slope a few years after we moved in. It grew larger and larger with intractable ivy crawling up its main trunk.  It never produced edible fruit and I didn't manage to successfully treat its annual leaf curl problem so it went on the removal list, as did a sapling it spawned.  The "after" photo is marred by sun spots but it shows how nice the Pittosporum 'Silver Magic' looks now that it's no longer hidden by the peach tree.

The removal also opens up space for the Ceanothus arboreus and the lemon tree located nearby.  I still have to cut back some of the tangled ivy left behind and should probably apply a stump killer to the base of the trees' trunks so they won't grow back.  As it is, I discovered that there's yet another peach tree sapling higher up the slope that I'd failed to identify.

The crew also cut a giant self-planted Pyracantha on the moderate slope facing the lath house flush to the ground.  I originally thought it was a Cotoneaster - until its vicious thorns showed themselves.  I'd tried to maintain it at a manageable size but it outgrew my efforts to contain it.

Its removal left a large area to be replanted

The stumps are still there so that's another problem I need to address

A lot of the smaller succulents below the Arbutus at the top of the slope and surrounding the Pyracantha were damaged or otherwise in need of a refresh.  Fortunately, the larger succulents nearby, including the Agave desmettiana, were undamaged.


I appreciate the airier look to my garden after the trees have been trimmed, as well as the additional light at ground level.  In addition, I think the trees and shrubs will be healthier for the work performed and I'm glad to be rid of the Pyracantha and the peach tree.  I've already returned everything we moved in advance of the work yet there's still a considerable amount to be done to put the garden in order, most notably a cleanup and replanting of the area previously covered by the Pyracantha and the area below it.  I'll probably rely heavily on succulent cuttings from elsewhere in my garden but this may be a plant shopping opportunity too!

As an aside, with the holidays approaching and various other stressors piling up, I'm tentatively planning to cut back my weekly blog posts from three to two per week at least through the end of the year.  At present, I expect to post on Monday and Friday each week.

Best wishes for a safe and pleasant weekend, whatever your weather.  I know that parts of the Pacific Northwest and Northern California are being hit hard by a Bomb Cyclone.  It's still not clear how coastal Southern California will be affected but it's looking more like we'll at least get at least a little measurable rain out of this system.


All material © 2012-2024 by Kris Peterson for Late to the Garden Party


26 comments:

  1. Wonder if the Copper Glow will start to weep and max out height...? Everything looks very nice. That pyracantha will spring back fast; mine was cut to the ground by someone else's tree trimmers and 2 years later is 12' tall. Although I'm relieved since it does double duty for me as a screen and bird feeder :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ugh, I guess I better apply the stump killer to the Pyracantha as soon as possible! The biggest issue is that, as it also sits at the upper portion of a moderate slope, it's not an easy shrub to manage.

      Delete
  2. You were probably holding your breath while the crew was working and relieved to put it behind you. A necessary, useful service, though stress inducing, I bet.
    I love the exposed trunks and limps throughout and, as always, the Arbutus is my favorite. The photo of the "interior of that tree's canopy" is just Wow! I could live in that gorgeous space.
    I'm always shocked by how fast they revert to their natural state, ready for next year's tree service!
    Chavli

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Arbutus in particular fill out swiftly, Chavli. Or at least that's been the case during the past 2 years of good rain. It's already looking as though this isn't going to be a good rain year - the storm that was headed our way this weekend now looks as though it'll be a bust.

      Delete
  3. It looks so good, I love how much light gets through. What a great refresh, and I'm glad you didn't suffer damage like last year. This is a great reminder that I need to schedule tree service. So far, we haven't had a drop of rain - if it doesn't get us today, I'm going to have to water. It's so dry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The rain we were expecting down this way is now looking unlikely too, Tracy. All of a sudden all the weather services are backing away from their earlier projections :(

      Delete
  4. You are such a good tree mom! Everything you showed looks so much better post-work.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Loree. I've already concluded that next year I need to include all or most of the 6 peppermint willows too!

      Delete
  5. The bomb cyclone knocked power out at Hannah's house for a few hours. They're on the beach a mile or so from our house on the Oregon coast. But nothing like the power outage in Washington state! Those tree service visits remind me of trips to the dentist -- lots of tension and anxiety but so much relief when over!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right, Denise - they really feel like visits to the dentist. It appears that that bomb cyclone may have given all its got to the Pacific Northwest. The likelihood of rain here has plummeted overnight.

      Delete
  6. I'm intrigued by your photos and I'm looking at the Arbutus closely. It looks like, in addition to thinning out branches, they take each branch back to the tips of the leaves? You have encourage me to consider pruning ours now in hopes that snow will not break it again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, they cut the branches too. The trees handle pruning very well, at least in my experience.

      Delete
  7. I am impressed with how well these appear to be pruned. I just assume that most tree service companies would be more hack and slash. Your photos show a more thoughtful thinning method that appears to have appreciated the overall form and structure of each tree. Looks great and you can really see the difference. You've got me considering whether we have enough of a project to get a trimming crew out here to where we live or whether I should still attempt things myself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As we've several areas where the ground is uneven and as my husband and I had a tumble in one situation when we tried to handle some trimming ourselves (nothing broken but it was a wake-up call), I've become more open to hiring out the bigger jobs. I've also had a good experience with this particular firm. Many of my neighbors hire cheaper services but it's worth it to pay a little more and get good work. (I always get an estimate in writing upfront.) The owner of the company is a certified arborist and he and his team know what they're doing. They also listen to me when I described exactly what I want done.

      Delete
  8. Wow, this was a MASSIVE project! I can only imagine the amount of trimmings that had to be chipped or hauled off. And of course the bill. I know that arborists aren't cheap!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'd thought about asking if the team could drop some of the trimmings that went through the huge chipper but I imagine any dump would have been deposited in the street, and there's no way I could've cleared it promptly! As the arborist owns the company, he provides the (free) review and estimate prior to the work and the guidance provided the crew when the work starts. When I first hired the company, I solicited estimates from 3 tree services - the one I selected is the only one run by an arborist and the price wasn't higher than the second bid or markedly higher than the third one. I may have just been lucky but it pays to shop around, especially when the project is extensive.

      Delete
  9. What is the tree trunk on the upper right in the last photo? Arbutus? It's very attractive. Looks like your crew did a good job. Great the owner is an arborist--they seem to care about trees more than most.

    Seems like thinning out a canopy too much would be stressful for a tree. I wonder about it because I see that a lot in this neighborhood--the homeowner doesn't want the trees to be pruned again for as many years as they can get away with, and some of them look pretty sparse (and still look pretty sparse, years later).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, that last photo shows the trunk of the largest Arbutus. The Arbutus all respond very well to significant thinning. The Agonis flexuosa (peppermint willows) do as well, although I didn't have any of those trimmed this year - they're on an every other year schedule.

      Delete
  10. You are fortunate to have found a reliable and competent tree service. There are a lot of questionable firms in that business-though in some cases the homeowner is the culprit. Yours did a nice job !

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I've seen LOTS of butcher jobs in the neighborhood!

      Delete
  11. Looks like they did a great job. It is hard to remove plants without upsetting the balance of the garden, but sometimes one must bite the bullet! I'm facing the same with a hemlock hedge that blocks the road from our front yard. I discovered it has become more severely infested with invasive woolly adelgids and at about 10-12' tall, it is has become more than 2 old folks can handle. We planted it 30+ years ago, now I feel like I'm a murderer. Gardeners can be rather emotional about their babies, ha! Oh, well, needs must... I must envision what I will plant in its stead! Eliza

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm sorry to hear about your hedge, Eliza. That's a big job, figuratively and literally. I hope you can find a suitable replacement.

      Delete
  12. What beautiful work they've done with minimal damage to existing plants. So appreciate the before/after shots you've included.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always appreciate the work the team puts in, even when there's some collateral damage. This round was remarkably low on that, although I also think I've become calmer about the whole process over the years.

      Delete
  13. That is what gardeners want - respect the shape and form of the tree - but lighter. Lots of careful work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I can always rely on this team for a job well done :)

      Delete

I enjoy receiving your comments and suggestions! Google has turned on reCAPTCHA affecting some commentator IDs so, if you wish to identify yourself, please add your name to your comment.